• Andy
    link
    fedilink
    17
    edit-2
    9 months ago

    I love canon and cross overs, but I’m fine with Netflix shows being their own universe. They’ve done so many multiverse shenanigans that it seems totally immaterial now whether the stuff we saw happened in the MCU world.

    It happened in A world. Maybe similar stuff happened in the MCU, but not exactly the same. That’s okay.

    Just focus on telling good stories. I’m less interested in canon now.

    • Omega
      link
      fedilink
      109 months ago

      So, officially shows like Agents of Shield, the Netflix Shows, The Runaways, Inhumans, Cloak and Dagger are all canon. There are some discrepancies, but they’re meant to be canon.

      I assume that everything that happens in one happens in the other, but the details might be a little off. If there is a discrepancy, what your watching takes precedence.

      I read a position that I’ve adopted that everything is technically a different canon. Every movie and show. So, even though things happen in both, anything off is accounted for, like Hulk or Thunderbolt Ross looking different, the time stamp on Homecoming not matching up, the multiversal events not meshing between MCU, comics, and Sonyverse, etc.

      • @CeruleanRuin
        link
        English
        29 months ago

        Now that time travel, branching timelines, and wildly different variants of characters and worlds are an established part of the MCU, they really should just lean into the loose canon philosophy that Doctor Who has embraced.

        That is, something is canon if it is useful to the story you are currently telling. If it contradicts that, then it is still canon, but took place in a different history that has since been altered or superceded by what’s happening now. Or it was a different timeline altogether.

        Just tell good stories, and people will forgive canon slippage.

    • Jo Miran
      link
      fedilink
      89 months ago

      I read “It happened in A world.” in the voice of that 90’s movie trailer guy voice.

  • @MimicJar@lemmy.worldM
    link
    fedilink
    69 months ago

    So the source for this all seems to be “they put them in the timeline order playlist on Disney+”.

    It certainly makes them more canon than not, but I don’t think this really changes anything.

    Without spoiling anything Echo makes it very clear you don’t need to have seen any of these series and if anything they want to move away from that concept.

    Really it comes down to Daredevil Born Again.

  • @ramble81@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    39 months ago

    MCU “canon” as they’re in Earth-19999 or just that there is connections though it may be another universe?

  • @wildcardology@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    29 months ago

    With the multiverse being open now anything that happened to a marvel character in another universe is canon right? I mean everything that happened in What If is canon.

    • @Mongostein@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      29 months ago

      Nothing in What If? has touched the MCU we’ve been following all this time. It’s still skippable. I imagine we’ll see some of the What If…? variants in Secret Wars though.

  • @CeruleanRuin
    link
    English
    19 months ago

    I suspect that this decision was made in an attempt to stem the bleeding. Marvel’s new stuff has not been consistently well-received, so they are appealing to nostalgia as they move forward with their multiverse plans.

  • @Mongostein@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    19 months ago

    ITT: people who still can’t accept that they are and always were canon.

    It’s ok to be wrong. Just let it go.