Of course, Hawaii: Part II is actually how I first encountered that group a number of years ago. If you really enjoy it, it’s also worth checking out some of the stuff that has come out of the solo careers of Rob Cantor and Joe Hawley. Rob Cantor has an album called NOT A TRAMPOLINE, and Joe Hawley has really carried the Tally Hall/Miracle Musical torch with the album Joe Hawley Joe Hawley. The Joe Hawley Joe Hawley album does feature all of the musicians in Tally Hall on some of its songs, which is awesome! Hawley also has a couple singles that are really great- “Since I Don’t Have You” and “Weird Bed &/or Yes Please.”
Hope these recommendations can help you keep on scratching your brain!
That’s super cool, hope you enjoy it! ^^