Logline
In Lagos, the mysterious Barber reigns supreme. The Doctor discovers a world where stories have power, but can he stop the Spider and its deadly web of revenge?
Written by: Inua Ellams
Directed by: Makalla McPherson
I really enjoyed this one. A nice tight mostly self contained sci-fi story, set in Lagos, but with some nice ties in to the wider plot.
Random aside, this isn’t the first time I’ve come across Lagos in a multi-dimensional sci fi story. M.R. Carey’s Pandominion series uses the locale to good effect. In a perfect world that shouldn’t really stand out but having been through enough London/New York focused stories from so many franchises it’s nice to see somewhere new take the role of global crossroads for interesting stories.
The idea of an engine powered by stories is a great sci fi concept. I did feel some of the elements were a tad in my face - the heart of the engine is a… heart? ok, ;). Imagery aside, one of the last lines is just wanting credit for your work, and that’s very timely given the current space of the creative landscape being very unforgiving for artists. Stories are a massive part of our culture, and sharing them, adapting them, remixing them to our needs, and then resharing them with yet more people is vitally important.
The inclusion of Martin’s doctor was totally unexpected, and I hope that eventually leads somewhere. I can see a lot of potential there. Exploring the full story with Anansi would be great.
Mrs Flood relies on the NHS for her meds. Something to rile up the “Doctor Who’s gone too woke” haters - An interdimensional immigrant using our healthcare (and I’ll bet Mrs Flood doesn’t even pay taxes)!
Flood Watch 2025
Uh…she goes to the hospital sometimes.
Well, that was no “Robot of Sherwood”…! /s
This was absolutely lovely. A story about stories, and about the Third Places where they are told, both being perverted for ulterior motives. The Barber’s grudge against the gods of stories made him repeat the perceived injustice done to himself. Hurt people hurt people, but the Doctor heals.
I’m probably going to mull over this for days to come, so for now just a bullet list of highlights that stand out after the first viewing:
- Loved the way they segued into the intro on the barbershop story displays. Fits perfectly with the meta narratives of the episode.
- All of the sets were so atmospheric and lived-in, what a great job giving character to the marketplace, the barbershop, even the backroom labyrinth and engine room.
- “I used to call it the World Wide Web, until the humans named something much uglier after it” (paraphrasing). I had to chuckle, and again later when the Doctor brought that back on him.
- Aw, of course Omo married the girl with the blue earrings! If you know you know 💙
- I cringed audibly at the bottom rung fantasy art renditions of the story gods — but the Doctor’s and Belinda’s immediate reaction to the Barber’s story they represented smoothed that over quickly. To me, the ridiculous artwork is now a signifier that it’s part of a ridiculous story.
- So wait, the Doctor retroactively hung out with a bunch of literal gods over the years? I thought the whole god/magic thing was supposed to be recent. But whatever, it fits this story and I’m rolling with it.
- The Fugitive Doctor! For all of thirty seconds! Whatever happens, we will only ever see too little of her. Jo Martin commands the screen, and her character is just bursting with potential.
- You can tell Inua Ellams has spent a lot of time with mythology, stories and their meanings. Abena’s explicit braid ruse was a nice story-based nod to more veiled messages. There is some of the same subject matter and deftness here as in some of Neil Gaiman’s better work — and that’s all we need say about him.
- The resolution to stopping the Barber’s plan had a bit of thematic repeat from “Rings of Akhaten” to me — but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t work here, as well! We’re all stories in the end. Just make it a good one (or two).
- I’m glad we didn’t see more of Mrs Flood than we did this week. Her appearances have begun to oversell the season arc a bit too much. But I guess the theory that she’s a pantheon god of stories is shot down after this episode.
It’s been a few years since I’ve been able to say with each successive episode of Doctor Who that “this one was even better than the last!” I may have little objections to one or other (“The well” didn’t need to be a sequel. “Lucky day” was too easy on UNIT), but this season just might be one for the ages — depending on how the finale lands…
This was one of the really unique episodes that defies description, and frankly I’m impressed you got as much mileage out of it as you did. I don’t think I have much to add. To revisit the comparison I made yesterday, it does share some things in common with one of my favourites, “Demons of the Punjab”, in its otherworldly vibes.
Edit: Actually, no. It’s not just otherworldly vibes. It’s that plus an exploration of a culture that’s not my own.
The Fugitive Doctor! For all of thirty seconds!
The little line/quip about her story maybe being complete one day made me chuckle - and of course, the Doctor’s story being neverending is part of the resolution.
There is some of the same subject matter and deftness here as in some of Neil Gaiman’s better work — and that’s all we need say about him.
Yeeeeeeeeah, I had the same thought. This sort of subject matter is something that Gaiman - scandal noted - excelled at.
And I have to agree, this season just might be an “all killer, no filler” season to rival the Ten/Donna season or Eleven’s first season.