There’s some fair clause that it is a genocide, though if it is, it goes both ways. That and most of the conditions that Palestine and Gaza put themselves in are from their own mistakes and faults in the past, such as declaring war a few times (and losing all of them), attacking their neighbouring countries and attacking Europe.
Not that this justifies Israel’s violence. They were killing innocent Arabs before Hamas.
Any intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group - in whole or in part - is genocide.
This includes killing people, causing severe bodily or mental harm, preventing births, forcibly transferring children to another group, or deliberately creating conditions calculated to bring about physical destruction.
Doing it counts. Conspiring to do it counts. Publicly inciting it to happen counts. Trying to do it obviously counts. Being complicit in any of that, counts.
This is the fucking UN definition of genocide. I am just barely paraphrasing from the relevant articles of convention. If you care more about tone-policing and gatekeeping than you do about an overt effort to dehumanize and kill a specific group in a specific region for ethnic and religious differences, you can eat shit.
Don’t bother. Mindbleach has been a perpetual spammer who just yells his moronic political stances and then acts like he’s superior by ignoring everything anyone else says.
Hey buddy? They both are. Israel is why Palestine is an open-air prison. Israel is the side that keeps killing those human shields, indiscriminately, without one shred of remorse. Apartments, hospitals, refugee centers, whatever.
Maybe inviting the world’s Jews to “go back to Africa” in the exact goddamn center of the Muslim middle-east was not a sensible idea, in terms of minimizing ethno-religious strife.
No country wanted to kill as many Germans as possible - they wanted the fucking war to end. They wanted to kill Hitler specifically, disrupt the Nazi regime, and go back to merely civilized levels of hating one another. Israel hasn’t fucking done that, with Palestine. Mostly they’ve just continued bombing. They’ve made token efforts to claim they want a rehabilitated Palestinian state… but always alongside collective abuses like the strict blockade that obviously leaves Israel in de-facto control of the region’s survival.
Arab-Muslims in the region was hard at work genocidig (per your definition) the Jewish population.
The most known example is the elimination of the Jewish community in 1929 from Gaza, the community lived there for hundreds of years. Other Jewish communities in the area was constantly attacked throughout the years.
The next major event was Arab countries kicking out all the Jews from their lands while steeling all their belonging. Which you defined as a genocide.
The old Muslim threat in the region was first Saturday, than Sunday. Meaning, first we get reed of the Jews, afterwards we take care of Christmas.
This still shapes older Jewish communities in Israel.
In 1977 the political map of Israel changed. Jewish politicians from Arab background took power.
Along with that, came harsher treatment of Palestinians.
The Palestinians had multiple chances of getting a country from left leaning Israeli politicians, with western background. They refused them all.
The secular Jewish population from European background is losing political power over time.
Meaning that even if Trump won’t kick them out, they won’t get many more oppertunities from the Israeli side.
tl;dr “inviting the world’s Jews to “go back to Africa” in the exact goddamn center of the Muslim middle-east” is pure bullshit, many, if not most, Jews already lived in the region.
Hey asshole - don’t split hairs about Gaza versus Palestine, then freely swap between Palestine and Hamas!
For the second and final time: saying you’re gonna do it is not the only thing that counts. Israel’s actions constitute genocide. What they say does not matter. The fact Hamas says it out loud neither absolves Israel nor condemns the rest of Palestine.
If Palestine gets their way, they’ll stop being a densely-populated ghetto amid fresh piles of rubble. Israel will stop using the actions of Hamas to justify killing X*10 number of Palestinians. Children and journalists will stop getting shot near the fuckoff enormous wall keeping them pressed against a sea they’re not really allowed to use.
Human shields did not bomb Israel. Declaring “THEY” keep doing it is collective punishment - also a war crime, by the way. All of this is two sides that fucking hate each other and keep doing obscene violence to each other, and your dumb ass wants to pretend it’s just a poor widdle innocent nuclear power being existentially threatened by people without consistent access to food.
Recently had someone argue Palestine isn’t genocide because the Arab population in Israel is going up.
Any obsession with birth rates is a red flag for brain worms, as surely as talking about skull shape.
There’s some fair clause that it is a genocide, though if it is, it goes both ways. That and most of the conditions that Palestine and Gaza put themselves in are from their own mistakes and faults in the past, such as declaring war a few times (and losing all of them), attacking their neighbouring countries and attacking Europe.
Not that this justifies Israel’s violence. They were killing innocent Arabs before Hamas.
Removed by mod
Any intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group - in whole or in part - is genocide.
This includes killing people, causing severe bodily or mental harm, preventing births, forcibly transferring children to another group, or deliberately creating conditions calculated to bring about physical destruction.
Doing it counts. Conspiring to do it counts. Publicly inciting it to happen counts. Trying to do it obviously counts. Being complicit in any of that, counts.
This is the fucking UN definition of genocide. I am just barely paraphrasing from the relevant articles of convention. If you care more about tone-policing and gatekeeping than you do about an overt effort to dehumanize and kill a specific group in a specific region for ethnic and religious differences, you can eat shit.
If not - we can talk.
Removed by mod
In light of the edit overtly declaring bigoted superiority, reported and blocked.
Removed by mod
Don’t bother. Mindbleach has been a perpetual spammer who just yells his moronic political stances and then acts like he’s superior by ignoring everything anyone else says.
Hey buddy? They both are. Israel is why Palestine is an open-air prison. Israel is the side that keeps killing those human shields, indiscriminately, without one shred of remorse. Apartments, hospitals, refugee centers, whatever.
Maybe inviting the world’s Jews to “go back to Africa” in the exact goddamn center of the Muslim middle-east was not a sensible idea, in terms of minimizing ethno-religious strife.
No country wanted to kill as many Germans as possible - they wanted the fucking war to end. They wanted to kill Hitler specifically, disrupt the Nazi regime, and go back to merely civilized levels of hating one another. Israel hasn’t fucking done that, with Palestine. Mostly they’ve just continued bombing. They’ve made token efforts to claim they want a rehabilitated Palestinian state… but always alongside collective abuses like the strict blockade that obviously leaves Israel in de-facto control of the region’s survival.
Some basic missing information there.
Arab-Muslims in the region was hard at work genocidig (per your definition) the Jewish population.
The most known example is the elimination of the Jewish community in 1929 from Gaza, the community lived there for hundreds of years. Other Jewish communities in the area was constantly attacked throughout the years.
The next major event was Arab countries kicking out all the Jews from their lands while steeling all their belonging. Which you defined as a genocide.
The old Muslim threat in the region was first Saturday, than Sunday. Meaning, first we get reed of the Jews, afterwards we take care of Christmas. This still shapes older Jewish communities in Israel.
In 1977 the political map of Israel changed. Jewish politicians from Arab background took power. Along with that, came harsher treatment of Palestinians. The Palestinians had multiple chances of getting a country from left leaning Israeli politicians, with western background. They refused them all.
The secular Jewish population from European background is losing political power over time. Meaning that even if Trump won’t kick them out, they won’t get many more oppertunities from the Israeli side.
tl;dr “inviting the world’s Jews to “go back to Africa” in the exact goddamn center of the Muslim middle-east” is pure bullshit, many, if not most, Jews already lived in the region.
Removed by mod
Have it your way.
Hey asshole - don’t split hairs about Gaza versus Palestine, then freely swap between Palestine and Hamas!
For the second and final time: saying you’re gonna do it is not the only thing that counts. Israel’s actions constitute genocide. What they say does not matter. The fact Hamas says it out loud neither absolves Israel nor condemns the rest of Palestine.
If Palestine gets their way, they’ll stop being a densely-populated ghetto amid fresh piles of rubble. Israel will stop using the actions of Hamas to justify killing X*10 number of Palestinians. Children and journalists will stop getting shot near the fuckoff enormous wall keeping them pressed against a sea they’re not really allowed to use.
Human shields did not bomb Israel. Declaring “THEY” keep doing it is collective punishment - also a war crime, by the way. All of this is two sides that fucking hate each other and keep doing obscene violence to each other, and your dumb ass wants to pretend it’s just a poor widdle innocent nuclear power being existentially threatened by people without consistent access to food.
Removed by mod
We? You’re not from Israel, are you? If not, then you should probably shut up.
Removed by mod
If you don’t have a citizenship, you don’t have much of an input.
You’ll need to chill tho
Removed by mod
No, I’m a mod, just letting you know you need to chill.
I’ve seen your comment history, you really need a snickers bar.