If the billboards in Ivanovo are to be believed, Russia’s really going places.

“Record harvest!”

“More than 2000km of roads repaired in Ivanovo Region!”

“Change for the Better!”

In this town, a four-hour drive from Moscow, a giant banner glorifying Russia’s invasion of Ukraine covers the entire wall of an old cinema. With pictures of soldiers and a slogan:

“To Victory!”

These posters depict a country marching towards economic and military success.

But there is one place in Ivanovo that paints a very different picture of today’s Russia.

I’m standing outside it. There’s a poster here, too. Not of a Russian soldier, but a British novelist. George Orwell’s face stares down at passers-by.

The sign above it reads The George Orwell Library.

Inside, the tiny library offers a selection of books on dystopian worlds and the dangers of totalitarianism.

There are multiple copies of Orwell’s classic novel Nineteen Eighty-Four; the story in which Big Brother is always watching and the state has established near-total control over body and mind.

“The situation now in Russia is similar to Nineteen Eighty-Four,” librarian Alexandra Karaseva tells me. “Total control by the government, the state and the security structures.”

In Nineteen Eighty-Four, the Party manipulates people’s perception of reality, so that citizens of Oceania believe that “war is peace” and “ignorance is strength”.

Russia today has a similar feel about it. From morning till night, the state media here claims that Russia’s war in Ukraine is not an invasion, but a defensive operation; that Russian soldiers are not occupiers, but liberators; that the West is waging war on Russia, when, in reality, it was the Kremlin that ordered the full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

“I’ve met people who are hooked on TV and believe that Russia isn’t at war with Ukraine, and that the West was always out to destroy Russia,” Alexandra says.

“That’s like Nineteen Eighty-Four. But it’s also like Ray Bradbury’s novel Fahrenheit 451. In that story the hero’s wife is surrounded by walls that are essentially TV screens, talking heads telling her what to do and how to interpret the world.”

It was a local businessman, Dmitry Silin, who opened the library two years ago.

A vocal critic of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, he wanted to create a space where Russians could “think for themselves, instead of watching TV”.

Dmitry was later prosecuted for “discrediting the Russian armed forces”. He’d been accused of scrawling “No to war!” on a building. He denied the charge. He has since fled Russia and is wanted by police.

Alexandra Karaseva gives me a tour of the library. It’s a treasure trove of literary titans from Franz Kafka to Fyodor Dostoevsky. There is non-fiction, too; histories of the Russian Revolution, of Stalin’s repressions, the fall of communism and of modern Russia’s failed attempts to build democracy.

The books you can borrow here are not banned in Russia. But the subject matter is very sensitive. Any honest discussion of Russia’s past or present can bring problems.

Alexandra believes in the power of the written word to bring change. That’s why she is determined the library stays open.

“These books show our readers that the power of autocratic regimes is not forever,” Alexander explains. “That every system has its weak points and that everyone who understands the situation around them can preserve their freedom. Freedom of the brain can give freedom of life and of country.”

“Most of my generation had no experience of grassroots democracy,” recalls Alexandra, who is 68. “We helped destroy the Soviet Union but failed to build democracy. We didn’t have the experience to know when to stand firm and say ‘You mustn’t do this.’ Perhaps if my generation had read Ninety Eighty-Four, it would have acted differently.”

Eighteen-year-old Dmitry Shestopalov has read Ninety Eighty-Four. Now he volunteers at the library.

“This place is sacrosanct,” Dmitry tells me. “For creative young people it’s a place they can come to find like-minded citizens and to get away from what’s happening in our country. It’s a little island of freedom in an unfree environment.”

As islands go, it is, indeed, little. Alexandra Karaseva is the first to admit that the library has few visitors.

“[My generation] helped destroy the Soviet Union but failed to build democracy… Perhaps if we had read Ninety Eighty-Four, we would have acted differently.” – Alexandra Karaseva, Librarian

By contrast, I find a large crowd in the centre of Ivanovo. It’s not Big Brother people have stopped to listen to. It’s a Big Band.

In bright sunshine an orchestra is playing classic Soviet melodies and people start dancing to the music. Chatting to the crowd I realise that some Russians are more than willing to believe what the billboards are telling them, that Russia’s on the up.

“I’m happy with the direction Russia’s heading in,” pensioner Vladimir tells me. “We’re becoming more independent. Less reliant on the West.”

“We’re making progress,” says a young woman called Natalya. “As Vladimir Putin has said, a new stage for Russia has begun.”

But what about Russia’s war in Ukraine?

“I try not to watch anything about that any more,” Nina tells me. “It’s too upsetting.”

Back at the George Orwell Library they’re holding an event. A local psychologist is finishing a lecture on how to overcome “learned helplessness” and believe you have the power to change your life. There are ten people in the audience.

When the lecture ends, librarian Alexandra Karaseva breaks the news.

“The building’s been put up for sale. Our library has to move out. We need to decide what to do. Where do we go from here?”

The library’s been offered smaller premises across town.

Almost immediately one woman offers her van to help with the move. Another member of the audience says she’ll donate a video projector to help the library. Others suggest ideas for raising money.

This is civil society in action. Citizens coming together in time of need.

Admittedly, the scale is tiny. And there’s no guarantee of success. In a society with less and less space for “little islands of freedom,” the library’s long-term future is uncertain.

But they’re not giving up. Not yet.

  • @trevron@beehaw.org
    link
    fedilink
    57 months ago

    As if the US isn’t exactly the same. It gets a little tiring that all the western countries are so sycophantic towards the US and post this garbage propaganda.

    • @millie@beehaw.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      32
      edit-2
      7 months ago

      It literally isn’t. Some states are pretty shit, but the US isn’t forcing people into exile for building libraries. And some states are great places where people have rights and the legislature is actually willing to protect its population from authoritarian policies.

      • @trevron@beehaw.org
        link
        fedilink
        97 months ago

        No, they are trying to imprison peaceful protesters for speaking out about another shitty country instead. Some scary shit happening with libraries too but that depends on the state.

        The US is beautiful. Many of the people are great. The policies, politicians, military industrial complex, infrastructure, healthcare, and the police are all shit though.

        The surveillance state and the propaganda is everywhere. It is eerily similar to Orwells 1984. Has been for a while. Thats all I am trying to point out.

        The US literally has slave labor as a punishment for crime in for profit prisons. The place is a joke as far human rights go.

        • @millie@beehaw.org
          link
          fedilink
          English
          27 months ago

          So, just to make this clear.

          The original goalpost was: “The US is exactly the same as Russia.” This being in the context of an article talking about Russian librarians being imprisoned and active extreme suppression of the free exchange of ideas being organized by the Russian government.

          There are certainly issues going on with libraries. John Oliver recently did an episode going over a lot of it. But the difference there is that these are largely organized by either fringe politicians or politicians in heavily right-wing states. I don’t really see evidence of it at a Federal level, which is what would be the equivalent to what’s going on in Russia. Even where some of this stuff is happening, it doesn’t seem to yet be as extreme as the situation there.

          Is it a similar and worrying pattern? Yes. Is it ‘exactly the same thing’? Definitely not.

          The US is extremely different from state to state, which can make getting anything done on a wide scale really chaotic, but it also means that we get to try new things and strike out on our own as a state if there’s popular support. That’s how we got marriage equality for queer folks, it’s how we legalized marijuana in a lot of states, and it’s what makes us able to do things like pass laws that protect people from other states’ repressive laws. We can do things like provide a safe haven for people seeking abortions who live in states where it’s illegal. There are states in the US that will literally take in trans folks as refugees from states with repressive laws. On the other hand, we have Florida, where there’s actually a no travel advisory for trans people because they’ll arrest us for trying to use a bathroom or having our gender on our driver’s license.

          And like, all this stuff you’re saying is absolutely true. It is a huge mess of near unchecked capitalistic greed in a lot of cases.

          But at this point we’ve moved the goal posts. Because they now seem to be “the US also has serious humanitarian problems”. Which, that’s true. But it doesn’t mean the same thing as “the US is exactly the same as Russia.”

          We have our own set of problems.

          • @trevron@beehaw.org
            link
            fedilink
            2
            edit-2
            7 months ago

            That is where you misinterpreted my words. I didn’t say the US is exactly the same as Russia. I was referring to the title quote from the article: “Russia now is like 1984”. The US is extremely similar to the surveillance/police state George Orwell describes.

            Regardless of that, as far as evil countries go, the US is 100% up there with Russia. You need only look at what the US does outside of its borders to confirm that. Both countries are constantly having a pissing contest and they will use whatever proxy country they can to fight each other. The US is extremely aggressive all around the globe. And it has never been to “install democracy.”

            They aren’t better inside the borders either. US citizens have a near 0% effect on federal policy, statistically speaking. That means that the representatives of the US are the military, intelligence agencies, lobby groups, and corporations.

            I will give you one snippet from an intelligence group: the CIA literally started the crack epidemic in America to fund their secret war against socialism (and actual democracy) in central/south america. That is insanely evil. Countless operations on citizen control and disinformation too. And they didn’t stop doing shady shit when they moved their operations to their NGO they started (National Endowment for Democracy). And most americans think those things are “just some conspiracy theories” which is exactly inline with my original point.

      • @trevron@beehaw.org
        link
        fedilink
        47 months ago

        I didn’t defend russia. Its just the tone of the article and the fact that the states are almost in parity with Orwells vision of a police state. I find it kind sycophantic that BBC will point out this russian thing but they won’t touch the police/surveillance infrastructure in the states which might as well have been modeled after that book.

        • @Megaman_EXE@beehaw.org
          link
          fedilink
          27 months ago

          If I may chime in, I believe you’re both correct in your own ways. Russia is being controlled through very “in your face” propaganda. America also, in many ways, is very controlling and also gets away with its fair share of atrocious behavior.

          In my opinion, it’s a spectrum or a big circle. Instead of being “left or right”, they both circle around to their own variation of authoritarianism.

          (although I would say the USA is slightly better off, for the time being, at least. I don’t think they’re quite as bad, but some aspects are indeed just as bad. But I have not visited Russia, so my perspective is skewed based purely on what I read about it.)

          • @trevron@beehaw.org
            link
            fedilink
            47 months ago

            I just don’t think most Americans realize the extent that they are propagandized. I don’t think most Europeans understand the full extent of it either. It is pretty crazy. I say this as someone who spent my first 30 years growing up in the US and then moved to Europe.

            • @Megaman_EXE@beehaw.org
              link
              fedilink
              27 months ago

              Oh, absolutely. We’re all subject to it. Even in ways that might confirm our own biases. It’s good to stop and try to think about what we’re reading/being told etc. But I think it’s super easy to not even realize

    • @DdCno1@beehaw.org
      link
      fedilink
      147 months ago

      What a dishonest and empty comment. I feel second hand embarrassment and shame for you. You know that that the US isn’t exactly the same, yet you chose to lie, just to defend a genocidal autocratic regime using the last line of defense any sycophants for dictatorships are using: Hypernormalization. After all, if everyone and everything is equally awful, your favorite oppressive machine maybe isn’t so bad. I’ve seen this exact line of reasoning, if one can call it that, used by defenders of Russia, Iran, China, Vietnam, North Korea, Hamas, Saudi Arabia, etc.

      I have one question for you: Why are you doing this? Are you a paid troll for the Internet Research Agency, fighting on the virtual front lines of the new Cold War so that you aren’t sent to the real front lines of the hot part of it, so that you aren’t end up as the main attraction of some Ukrainian drone bombing video, dying slowly to the sound of some questionable music? Are you perhaps a delusional Western Tankie who is still reflexively applauding to everything Moscow is doing, despite the fact that the “evil West” you’ve been indoctrinated (or indoctrinated yourself) to hate is now far more left than the currently extremely far-right Russia? Or perhaps you are much further to the right and simp for Russia precisely because it aligns itself so well with your belief system, e.g. in regards to its oppression of ethnic and sexual minorities, its violent imperialistic politics, the macho strongman aesthetics the insecure leader is cultivating.

      Which of these is it?

      • @trevron@beehaw.org
        link
        fedilink
        57 months ago

        I hope you don’t need to draw conclusions in your line of work because that was pathetic. What an insane response to a very casual recognition of the American police state.

        I am not even defending Russia, its just the same neo-liberal police state bullshit that happens to also exist in the US. Not all states are equally in your face about it but your rights barely exist and if you can’t see that then you aren’t paying attention.

        I am not a tankie, just a person that is capable of observation. But that is the most typical anti-socialist rhetoric just because I point out that the US is just as vile as all the oppressors.

        The fact that you included Hamas and not Israel in your shit stain of a comment means I don’t have to take you seriously though.

        • @DdCno1@beehaw.org
          link
          fedilink
          97 months ago

          your rights barely exist

          I’m not American.

          I point out that the US is just as vile as all the oppressors

          That’s not pointing out anything, because it’s flat out wrong. For all its faults, the US not as bad, not even close and nobody sane would make this claim. You are doing nothing but normalizing actual oppressors with this.

          The fact that you included Hamas and not Israel

          I don’t think you are quite aware of just how stark the difference between Israel and Hamas is - or you’re deliberately ignoring it. Tel Aviv is considered one of the most gay-friendly cities in the world - whereas in Palestinian territories, gay people are being publicly tortured and executed. That’s just one aspect. The difference between Israel and Palestinian territories in regards to civil liberties is about as stark as the one between the two Koreas. This doesn’t mean Israel is perfect, far from it, but the fact that you feel the need to lie about yet another topic and in the same sentence excrete a vile insult doesn’t exactly make you look like a reasonable person.

          • @trevron@beehaw.org
            link
            fedilink
            47 months ago

            You are the one who started accusing me of some BS. I never once lied. Your conclusion jumping and implied accusations are very revealing to what type of person I am talking to.

            You have to ignore what the US has been doing around the world for 70+ years to come to that conclusion. Doesn’t matter if some states are okay if the feds start wars and coups and destabilize regions in the name of profit.

            As far as Israel goes, being pro-LGBTQ doesn’t mean anything when the entire basis of zionism and their state is xenophobic as fuck. You don’t get to cherry pick which human rights to respect in order to seem progressive.

            Israel’s history is full of oppression and lies and I am not going to have it out with you when it is clear that you are absolutely unreasonable. No one should take you seriously.

            They are also afraid of real democracy which is why they have infested the US with the shittiest politicians through AIPAC.

            Don’t try to teach me about Palestine via Israeli propaganda lol

            • @DdCno1@beehaw.org
              link
              fedilink
              2
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              You don’t get to cherry pick which human rights to respect in order to seem progressive.

              The way you casually threw away a human rights aspect you don’t care about can only be called cherry-picking. That’s really all that needs to be said in response to this gish gallop.

              • @trevron@beehaw.org
                link
                fedilink
                27 months ago

                Poor reading comprehension maybe? I didn’t casually throw away anything, I pointed out that if you are a racist piece of shit, then you aren’t automatically a good person for not being homophobic.

                Pretty straight forward concept.