I love the original patientgamers subreddit so I was stoked to find this community. And because lemmy seems to have a more knowledgeable crowd any topic I posted here had great engagement and discussions, despite the small community. I am too busy to be a mod but maybe I can help by sparking this discussion: what would be needed to keep this sub going?

  • @tal@lemmy.today
    link
    fedilink
    English
    77 months ago

    I liked the weekly/bi-weekly „What are you playing“ posts, but they seem to have stopped, even on the bigger „games“ subs.

    Well, !gaming@beehaw.org and !games@sh.itjust.works both have stickied posts from this week of that sort up with activity. How many gaming subs do you read?

    • @caut_R@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      117 months ago

      I‘m on another patient gamers sub, and the games sub on lemmy.world. The biggest weakness of Lemmy IMO is how fractured communities can become due to very similar subs on different instances - which this is now an example of, I suppose, since I had no idea about the ones you mentioned lol

      I‘ll check them out later, although it obviously doesn‘t help this sub specifically

      • @bassomitron@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        47 months ago

        The biggest weakness of Lemmy IMO is how fractured communities can become due to very similar subs on different instances

        Agreed, and also why I think Lemmy will never progress past a niche audience despite being capable of doing so. It’d be nice if there was a feature that allowed instances to merge all like-named communities into a singular one. I know cross posting was meant to help address the problem, but that’s a manual process that falls quite short in resolving the core issue.

        • @tal@lemmy.today
          link
          fedilink
          English
          2
          edit-2
          7 months ago

          I don’t think it’s that fundamental. I mean, Reddit has one shared namespace for subreddit names, but that doesn’t mean that everyone has to use one keyword. Like, you have /r/guns and /r/firearms, stuff like that. Nothing merges those.

          And even for /r/patientgamers, there’s overlap. Like, /r/patientgamers probably has a fair bit of overlap with /r/retrogaming (note: !retrogaming@lemmy.world and !retrogaming@kbin.social exist) and /r/truegaming.

          I do think that making lemmyverse.net’s search feature or something similar that spans multiple instances to help people find communities across many instances more easily would help, and putting support for that in clients. The Threadiverse model of having an instance not index communities until someone on an instance subscribes helps scalability, but if the main way to search for communities only searches communities that an instance knows about, it kind of kills discoverability for users.

          • @bassomitron@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            English
            27 months ago

            In regard to Reddit having the same problem, I agree it does to an extent. But like you said, it only allows for synonyms or alternate wording for the same topic in a subreddit’s name. On Lemmy, since instances are different, the fractured communities can be named the exact same thing. Most casual users are not going to realize this and think that the one community they’re in is not active when on another instance, the other like-named community might have grown and is now quite active since they initially setup their subscriptions. They’ll never know unless they happen to run another search and see the alternate community’s user count.

            Maybe I’m wrong and it isn’t a big deal. But I do agree that searching and indexing would be a great step in helping discoverability.

            • @tal@lemmy.today
              link
              fedilink
              English
              3
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              There’s some site that’s designed just to use a bot account on various major instances to subscribe a new community. It waits until there are something like 10 regular users subscribed, then unsubscribes. You could just plonk in a community name and have it do so. That helps discoverability but kind of clashes with the whole intended scalability decision in lemmy/kbin/etc design not to slurp in content from all communities out there.

              I think this is the github project page, but someone was running an instance of it.

              googles

              Man, I can’t even find the instance that someone was running, which does kind of maybe highlight the need for a central “Threadiverse wiki” that links to all this stuff. fediverse.observer, lemmyverse.net, fedidb.org, join-lemmy.org, etc. There’s some other tool that someone made to measure post federation latency, so you could see what instances are overloaded or not working. There are a ton of useful tools out there, but no central hub. I keep finding them when someone links to them on the Threadiverse and then never being able to find them again.

              My own home instance, lemmy.today, has always had a request in the sidebar asking people to subscribe to a bunch of communities so that they become visible to the instance, which seems like kind of an awkward workaround for discoverability:

              🥹 Make sure to join a lot of remote communities to get a good feed going. How to do that is explained here.

        • @can@sh.itjust.works
          link
          fedilink
          17 months ago

          It’d be nice if there was a feature that allowed instances to merge all like-named communities into a singular one.

          Who would decide how it’s run? Different communities with the same name may have different rules or content in mind.

      • @tal@lemmy.today
        link
        fedilink
        English
        3
        edit-2
        7 months ago

        I‘m on another patient gamers sub, and the games sub on lemmy.world.

        Heh, fair enough.

        I had no idea about the ones you mentioned lol

        If you hit lemmyverse.net, they’ve got a “search all instances by communities by name” feature, which I think is probably currently the most-realistic way to find communities across all of the Threadiverse.

        https://lemmyverse.net/communities

        Note that their kbin indexing isn’t great – you need to explicitly choose “kbin magazines” from the upper-right hamburger menu; it doesn’t combine kbin and lemmy results. And they don’t currently index at least kbin.social, which is the largest kbin instance.

      • @can@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        3
        edit-2
        7 months ago

        Beehaw deliberately cuts theirs* off from two of the biggest Lemmy instances so I wouldn’t expect much there.

        • @tal@lemmy.today
          link
          fedilink
          English
          3
          edit-2
          7 months ago

          Ohhhh, that’s a good thought. Beehaw.org’s pretty aggressive about defederation when they have problems with users. I’m on lemmy.today, and they haven’t defederated from there, so I’m still seeing what’s current on there.

          Well, a direct link to see what’s on there, bypassing defederations: https://beehaw.org/c/gaming

          • CommunityLinkFixerBotB
            link
            English
            47 months ago

            Hi there! Looks like you linked to a Lemmy community using a URL instead of its name, which doesn’t work well for people on different instances. Try fixing it like this: !gaming@beehaw.org

            • @tal@lemmy.today
              link
              fedilink
              English
              37 months ago

              I…appreciate the effort, bot. It’s good to know that you’re looking out for us.