This is the problem with using VPN services in general, you have to have complete trust in the service provider.

  • mox
    link
    fedilink
    7
    edit-2
    8 months ago

    What’s important here is not the source code, but whether the service collects unnecessary information.

    Craigslist does a pretty good job of respecting privacy.

    • ian
      link
      fedilink
      28 months ago

      I agree. However, I think that most people won’t use Craigslist simply because it doesn’t have a lot of the modern niceties, specifically modern messaging solutions. The email system they have is pretty painful to use.

      • mox
        link
        fedilink
        38 months ago

        It’s easy enough to do messaging via text, or whatever other contact info you choose to give out. I like that I can use Craigslist without giving them much info about myself.

        If you’re suggesting that a messaging system built into the venue is critical for success, then I suppose all of us wanting privacy are out of luck for now… but perhaps Craigslist (or some other privacy-friendly venue) could make it happen by integrating Matrix.

        • ian
          link
          fedilink
          18 months ago

          I agree that most messaging services are problematic, but Facebook having Messenger is part of the moat that’s keeping FB users on Marketplace. I think offering any non-email messaging solution would be hugely beneficial. I like the Matrix idea quite a bit.

          • mox
            link
            fedilink
            48 months ago

            Europe’s new Digital Markets Act might help in this department, too, through legally mandated interoperable messaging. Let’s hope it works out in our favor.

    • strawberry
      link
      fedilink
      08 months ago

      Craigslist also doesn’t have shit on it. try and buy a car on there. if you’re looking for a beater, sure. but a halfway decent sports car, fb marketplace is the only place

      its still OK for other stuff, I’ve bought tools and whatnot off Craigslist, but for vehicles fb is unfortunately still king

      • mox
        link
        fedilink
        7
        edit-2
        8 months ago

        What you’re describing is the network effect in action, not a flaw in Craigslist.

        (It will be the same with every alternative you find, except perhaps one that’s well funded with outside money, which will be awful on the privacy front, of course.)

        The way we overcome a network effect is piece by piece:

        • First we switch to the privacy-friendly service for everything we can. That immediately reduces our exposure, reduces the power of the incumbent, and makes the alternative more useful by giving more users a reason to switch.
        • Then, over time, we switch for the remaining things as we find a suitable service for each one. (This might even be the same privacy-friendly alternative we started with, after it has grown a little.)

        If I felt I had to buy a sports car, and some awful invasive site like Facebook was somehow the only viable venue, I would buy just the car there. I wouldn’t make them the middle man for every other transaction in my life.

        • strawberry
          link
          fedilink
          28 months ago

          well yea its not Craigslist itself that’s the issue, its the fact that its a smaller platform. and yea I use eBay or Craigslist for everything but vehicles.its sad that Craigslist has been forgotten though.