I’m just sitting here thinking about all the hoopla around palworld right now and I was wondering what other titles out there have been in the controversy filled category in the past few years/decade? I can think of a few, but my game interests are kinda narrow.

What are some of your picks?

  • Pleb
    link
    fedilink
    111 months ago

    it feels like an exception when a remaster is generally appreciated.

    Don’t think I ever heard something bad about the Starcraft remaster.
    The Yakuza Kiwami games are supposedly good too, but I never played them or the originals.
    The Resident Evil games are more like remakes, the only bad thing I heard is about 4. But that was from the perspective of challenge runners, apparently some weirdness going on there. But supposedly absolutely fine for casual gaming, but I never played any of these either.

    • Hydroel
      link
      fedilink
      111 months ago

      Off the top of my head:

      • I don’t remember which one, but one recent Resident Evil remaster. Must be 4, if you say so!
      • As I mentioned, Warcraft III: Reforged was (is?) considered terrible
      • The GTA III, GTA: Vice City and GTA: San Andreas remasters, which are pretty bad ports of the Android/iOS versions
      • Batman: Return to Arkham
      • Dark Souls: Remastered
      • Metro 2033: Redux
      • Halo: The MCC as well, although I heard that it got a lot better down the line
      • Didn’t some Final Fantasy recent remasters / new releases get criticized?

      From what I recall, most of these were criticized for lacking the hand-crafted textures and lighting that the originals had. For obvious reasons, since most remasters are AI-enhanced textures, upgraded engines and little to no handcraft ever comes into play.