• @zarkanian@sh.itjust.works
    2•9 months ago

    If everybody played from the same deck, it would be a different game. They could sell it in non-randomized boxes instead, though. It would still be expensive, just much, much less expensive.

    For example, the modern version of Netrunner is like this. Each player still builds their own decks, but the cards aren’t blind buys. Every box of cards has the exact same cards.

    • Flying Squid
      2•9 months ago

      But that’s sort of built into the game, isn’t it? The idea that the playability depends on continued purchases. But you can have similar games with similar playability that you spend $30 on or whatever and they might have expansion sets for it, but it’s not all based on either spending a small amount of money and having good luck or spending a large amount of money.

      Think about arguing that loot boxes were necessary for a video game. That might be true for that game, but it’s because the game was designed around buying loot boxes. And there are probably games which have at least relatively similar gameplay but don’t have the loot box thing. And maybe you’re okay with paying for those loot boxes. They wouldn’t have loot boxes in games if people weren’t willing to pay for them. That’s fine if that’s what you want to spend your money on, but it is not something I can personally justify with my own money.

      • @zarkanian@sh.itjust.works
        2•9 months ago

        But that’s sort of built into the game, isn’t it?

        No, I don’t think it is, and the reason why is because nothing in the gameplay necessitates random purchases. That isn’t part of the game. In fact, several CCGs have gone from a blind-buy model to a fixed-distribution model and the gameplay has not changed at all. They did this with Netrunner, Call of Cthulhu, and some others. Fantasy Flight has a whole line of these called “Living Card Games”.

        It’s easy to imagine Magic being sold in a similar way: instead of randomized boosters, you buy boxes of cards that contain 4 of each card, you build your decks, and off you go.

        At the highest levels of play, money isn’t a factor. The players who win Magic tournaments aren’t the ones with the most money. If that were true, it would obviously be a broken game, and nobody would be playing it anymore. Instead, wealth is a gatekeeper. You have to have a certain amount of expendable wealth to be able to play at the highest levels. If you made all of the cards equally accessible, it would change nothing except lowering the bar to entry.